I would use this site much if some of the following issues were addressed...
01) the html coding could use some debugging
02) the look of the site is bland and unappealing. Since the focus is on directors you might want to use a director's chair as a logo for the site. Then I would use different shades of black and white to give the entire site a look of a classic silent film. Take a look at my site's design
http://www.jamesbradfordhuston.com/. I would enjoy joining the team to help create a visually catching appeal to the site.
03) The rating system on this site is horrible. It leaves lots of room for confusion. The best rating system on the web can be found on a site called Newground
http://hydrozero.newgrounds.com/. Not only that, but they have this terrific idea of daily and weekly winners. This means that if you have an accurate rating system then people who are visiting the site for the first time will probably take a look at daily and weekly winners.
04) Everyone gets one vote. It's just fair and more accurate to write in some html code for that sort of thing.
05) Besides Newground, deviantART
http://jameshuston.deviantart.com/ is also a great site to borrow ides from. I personally like customization. People like having avatars and a fun user page. Maybe borrow from Myspace when letting people create user pages wouldn't be so bad.
06) finally, I would create an annual awards program with similar categories to the Oscars. Through out the year individuals can earn "nomination points" for various categories.
07) the general layout is a little confusing. A small tweak should fix that issue
Well I've thought of all I could think of. I hope that my ideas are non intrusive and helpful. If I don't here back from you I wish you luck on the undertaking.